|
Olanike Ola
Orie
This paper examines
phonological attrition in Trinidad Yoruba (TY), and argues that attested
patterns result from convergence and language acquisition reversal. Warner-
Lewis (1997), based on comparative data from TY and Yoruba (Y) dialects of
West
Africa, shows that 2nd/3rd generation TY speakers exhibit the following
phonological
patterns. For example, labial-velar consonants (kp, gb) are simplified to
labials or velars
(gbogbo ‘all’ bobo, gogo); complex tones are simplified
to register tones (LLH becomes LH); nasal vowels are realized as nasal
vowels or denasalized to oral vowels (sun becomes su ‘sleep’). Warner-Lewis
analyzed these patterns as resulting from the convergence of TY, Trinidad
English and French Creoles.
However, some patterns are not accounted for in Warner-Lewis’
analysis, for instance: (1) [y] is shown to replace [l] in Y words such as
demOlE ‘cover’ and lO ‘go,’ realized as demaye and yO;
(2) a process of rounding harmony is attested in TY, which is not found in
any Y dialect or the Trinidad Creoles. This process changes an unrounded
word-initial vowel to a rounded vowel if the second vowel in the word is
round: ekurO ‘palm kernel’ okurO; (3) the absence of complex
tones is unexplained.
It is argued that these patterns are not caused by convergence
but by reversal in language acquisition (LA). Evidence is given from Yoruba
first language acquisition and post-lingual deafness to show that TY
patterns occur in earlier stages of acquisition. Finally, the fact that
fully acquired forms (for example, nasal vowels) are found in TY, shows,
contrary to Cook (1995), that phonological attrition in TY is not due to
semi-speakers’ impeded and prematurely terminated learning process.
|